<span class="aioseo-breadcrumb"> <a href="https://www.tfp.org/are-american-universities-sacrificing-objectivity-for-ideology/" title="Are American Universities Sacrificing Objectivity for Ideology?">Are American Universities Sacrificing Objectivity for Ideology?</a> </span>

Are American Universities Sacrificing Objectivity for Ideology?

Are American Universities Sacrificing Objectivity for Ideology?
Are American Universities Sacrificing Objectivity for Ideology?

A long-overdue discussion may be beginning among America’s leading liberal arts scholars. The keyword is “objectivity,” and the absence of this necessary ingredient accounts for many of the problems in the American university over the last generation.

Asking an Important Question

This guarded optimism is found in a recent opinion piece in The Washington Post. Its author is Daniel Diermeier, the chancellor of Vanderbilt University. He and his counterpart at Washington University in St. Louis, Andrew D. Martin, commissioned a committee of scholars to consider a tremendously important question: “whether ideological commitments were eroding scholarly standards and distorting the objective pursuit of knowledge.” In other words, do scholars place their preconceived assumptions over the facts that they are supposed to be studying?

The report that this committee devised carries a cumbersome title, Report on the State of Scholarship in the Humanities and the Humanistic Social Sciences. However, it begins with a brief and yet elegant description of the value of the humanities.

“The humanities and the social sciences take as their subject matter human culture and society, in the past, present and future. Their common aim is to help us understand the human world and to develop in their students the capacity to participate intelligently in society, to comprehend their place in history, to appreciate the great works of the imagination, and also to identify the most significant defects in human life and their sustaining causes.”

The Nature of Objectivity

Objectivity is one of the most important gifts that God gave to humanity. Its purpose is to assist in determining the truth. The ability to set aside preconceived notions and look squarely at a problem, isolating pertinent aspects of the issue from attractive deceptions, is one of the triumphs of human logic. In fact, it is reasonable to say that every truth, other than those that came through direct divine inspiration, has been attained through the use of the objective faculty.

The use of objectivity begins with asking intelligent questions. Then, the academic’s task is to collect all available evidence and analyze as many arguments as possible, while evaluating which arguments best fit the evidence. This process can take years, even generations, but the goal is always the same—finding the objective truth that will stand the test of time.

Lamentably, over the last two generations, this noble and useful work has been subordinated by two groups of pseudo-scholars, both of whom spring primarily (although not exclusively) from the ideological left. The first group consists of those who see the very ideas of truth and its related concepts, reason and knowledge, as non-existent. The second are those who subvert objectivity to their political concerns, particularly those often referred to as “social justice warriors.”

Owning No Truth

Those who see truth as relative disdain the goal of objectivity altogether. They cloaked their anti-scholarship in Nietzsche’s words: “There are no facts, only interpretations.” Adopting this premise as their starting point, they developed obsessions with “my truth,” “your truth,” and “lived experience” as the basis of their intellectual structure. In so doing, they were, at least in their own minds, unassailable. If there is no standard of truth, no assumption or conclusion—no matter how absurd—can ever be accepted as true or rejected as false.

However, this brand of reasoning leads nowhere except ever deeper into the state sometimes described as “the hell of self,” where personal experience and whim become the wellspring of all (false) understanding. Objectivity is commonly rejected, even to the extent of having been listed as one of the Smithsonian Institute’s infamous “Aspects and Assumptions of Whiteness and White Culture.”

It is easy to dismiss the analysis of this first group, because their ruminations often go nowhere and solve no problems.

Substituting Politics for the Truth

The far more dangerous group is those who willfully abandon objectivity because it does not suit their political purposes. The idea is that evidence and arguments that do not lead to the desired conclusion are simply ignored. An excellent example of this is the left’s current obsession with race as the primary determinant of success or failure in modern Western society. The antiracist goal of “social justice” must be served. Any argument that promotes that goal is true; any analysis that detracts from it is false.

“Scholars” of this ilk distort basic ideas of right and wrong, amplify facts or coincidences that promote their ideologies, and silence those who disagree. Consider this quotation from the oracle of anti-racism, Ibram X. Kendi, in his book, How to Be an Antiracist. “The good news is that racist and antiracist are not fixed identities. We can be a racist one minute and an antiracist the next. What we say about race, what we do about race, in each moment, determines what—not who—we are.”

The Importance of Definitions

On first reading, these three sentences carry a veneer of wisdom, as though Dr. Kendi has thought long and hard about these issues. Only upon reflection do the deficiencies become apparent. The whole train of thought is based upon a whim, rather than an objective study.

However, compare that statement with Merriam-Webster’s definition of racist, “having, reflecting, or fostering the belief that race is a fundamental determinant of human traits and capacities and that racial differences produce an inherent superiority of a particular race.”

By that definition, one can evaluate the words or actions of another person (or even one’s own), and determine whether or not that person is a racist. However, such a definition does not suit Dr. Kendi, because by it, he could be described as a racist himself. Being subject to such a charge could bring his whole intellectual edifice crashing to the ground. So, he creates a new, largely meaningless non-definition that heightens insecurity among those left wondering, “Is it I?”

A Fruitless and Chaotic Search

Obviously, this is not the way to find the truth either. Discarding certain evidence and arguments simply because they do not fit the researchers’ prior assumptions can yield nothing of lasting value. The primary goal of any such study should be to find answers, not simply to further the goals of one or another interested group.

Abandoning objectivity creates chaos. It leads to the idea that destroying and looting someone else’s property leads to justice. It turns murders into objects of pity and allows people to ignore the abundant evidence that Marxism leads only to greater poverty and despair.

It is easy to see such tendencies in the modern university—and in many lower schools as well. As this landmark study concludes, “As we have already noted, there are those in academia who would question the value of disinterested inquiry, or even its possibility. But as we have argued, these doubts are the product of philosophical confusion; there is in fact no good reason to question either the coherence or the value of disinterested inquiry, however difficult it may be…. They are not mere problems in the administration or operation of a university, but they strike at the very heart and soul of what a university should be.”

Related Articles: